Why buyback sites lower their price after you post your phone
How a typical buyback quote works
The instant price you see was never a firm offer. It was an estimate that depended on an inspection that hadn't happened yet.
Four reasons the price drops
1. Condition labels mean different things to different people
A label like "Good" sounds forgiving, but on some sites it can mean a phone with no visible scratches at all. If you don't read the small print behind each label, it's easy to choose a grade higher than the buyer will accept.
2. Every phone is different
A drop-down has three or four options. Real phones have a light scratch near the camera, a small chip on one corner, or a battery at 84%. None of that fits neatly into a list, so the inspector makes the call, not you.
3. The headline price is the best case
Instant prices are often shown as "up to" a figure. That figure is for a phone in the best version of the condition you picked.
4. The check comes after you've let go of the phone
This is the big one. By the time anyone looks at your phone, it's already with the buyer. If the offer drops, you're deciding from a weaker position.
What happens when the offer is lowered
You usually have two choices: accept the lower price, or ask for the phone back. You can also try appealing to the buyer first. Getting the phone back can take days, and some sites charge a return or admin fee, so check before you send. Faced with that, many sellers simply accept the lower offer.
How to protect yourself
- Read the condition definitions before you pick one, not just the label.
- Photograph your phone before posting: front, back, all four edges, and the screen switched on.
- Check your battery health in Settings, under Battery, and take a screenshot.
- Check the return policy. Find out whether you'd pay to get your phone back if you refuse a lower offer.
- Keep your proof of postage.
- Consider a buyer that checks first. If the price is confirmed before you post, the inspection can't surprise you later.
Checked after posting, or checked before?
| Checked after you post | Checked before you post | |
|---|---|---|
| How your price is set | You pick a condition from a drop-down | A specialist looks at your phone's details |
| When your phone is looked at | After it has arrived | Before you send it |
| When you know your final price | After inspection | Before you post |
| If you disagree with a lower offer | Your phone is already with the buyer | Your phone is still in your hand |
How AsQuoted does it
We built AsQuoted around checking first. You spend around two minutes showing us your iPhone. A real specialist reviews it and emails you a confirmed price. If your phone arrives as you showed it, we pay that price in full by bank transfer the same day.
Sellers who have reviewed us on Trustpilot mention being paid the price they were quoted, quotes arriving the same day, and payment landing the day their phone arrived. See how our quote works.
Quick questions
Can a buyback site legally lower its offer?
Yes, if its terms say the price depends on inspection, which most do. You don't have to accept the new offer.
Do I have to accept a lower offer?
No. You can ask for your phone back. Check first whether the site charges for the return.
How long does it take to have a phone checked before posting?
With AsQuoted, showing us your phone takes around two minutes, and a specialist typically confirms your price within 3 hours during business hours.
Sources
- MoneySavingExpert: mobile phone recycling guide (updated 5 October 2026)
- Trustpilot: reviews of asquoted.co.uk
Sources checked on 16 November 2026. Prices and settings can change, so check the original pages for the latest details.